Skip to main content clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile
Hudson River Blue homepage Horizontal - White Hudson River Blue a New York City FC community

Follow Hudson River Blue online:

  • Follow Hudson River Blue on Twitter
  • Follow Hudson River Blue on Facebook
Log in or sign up
  • Log In
  • Sign Up

Site search

Hudson River Blue main menu

  • New York City FC
  • HRB Store
  • NYCFC II
  • Gotham FC
  • Features
  • Write for Hudson River Blue
  • Fanposts
  • Community Guidelines
  • DraftKings Nation
  • Archive
  • Masthead
  • More
All 300 communities on Horizontal - White
  • New York City FC
    • Transfers, Trades, Rumors
    • 2023 NYCFC Preseason
    • Schedule and Results
    • Stadium Saga
    • Tactics, Formations, Analysis
    • Game Day Hub
    • Game Recaps
    • Bielsa Report
    • NYCFC Academy
    • Hudson River Derby
    • Lamar Hunt US Open Cup
    • Leagues Cup
    • MLS Cup Playoffs
    • CONCACAF Champions League
    • Campeones Cup
  • HRB Store
  • NYCFC II
  • Gotham FC
  • Features
    • MLS Monday
    • Soccer Culture
    • HRB Roundtable
    • Exclusive Interviews
    • Footy Digest
    • International Call-Ups
    • New York Soccer Scene
    • Kits and Merch
    • Stadium Saga
    • City Football Group News
  • Write for Hudson River Blue
  • Fanposts
  • Community Guidelines
  • DraftKings Nation
  • Archive
  • Masthead

Filed under:

3 Montreal Impact Questions with SB Nation’s Mount Royal Soccer

John Richan answers our Impact questions as the teams prepare for their showdown Sunday.

By JakeGofman@JakeGofman Jul 16, 2016, 3:43pm EDT

Share this story

  • Share this on Facebook
  • Share this on Twitter
  • Share All sharing options

Share All sharing options for: 3 Montreal Impact Questions with SB Nation’s Mount Royal Soccer

  • Reddit
  • Pocket
  • Flipboard
  • Email
Jean-Yves Ahern-USA TODAY Sports

New York City FC squares off with the Montreal Impact this Sunday in a pivotal Eastern Conference showdown. NYC's lead at the top is precarious following their loss to Sporting KC, and pressure is on to get a result against the likes of a dangerous Montreal Impact team lurking in the top four.

Mount Royal Soccer writer John Richan stops by the blog to answer our Impact questions, giving us the scoop on the team's recent run of form, the tactical changes that have improved the side, and the chemistry forming in the defense.

Q. Montreal quietly sits within striking distance of first place in the Eastern Conference, four points back with two games in hand on our NYC FC. The team has put together an unbeaten run of six straight (4 draws and 2 wins) and from what I have read, at least two of these draws (KC and RSL) probably should have resulted in wins. What is at the root of the unbeaten run of form for Montreal over the past five weeks? Is there a underlying issue that accounts for the dropped points late in matches?

J. Finding consistency has been one of the biggest challenges this season for the Impact (even with all the draws). Montreal is going through a stretch where almost everything they do seems to end up in a draw. On the plus side, this has probably been the most successful season they have ever had in terms of road performances. Even though some may be disappointed with the last two draws, getting points on the Road against Real Salt Lake and Portland Timbers is impressive. On the flip side of things, dropping points has felt disappointing at times and I think some of this can be attributed to injuries and player absences up to this point. Midfielder Marco Donadel and defender Donny Toia have missed much of the season to this point while Laurent Ciman missed nearly a month with Belgium as part of Euro 2016.

Q. I've seen that Montreal, quite like NYC FC, has been prone to formation changes this season. After its draw with Sporting KC, Mount Royal's Javier Gonzalez called for a formation change from 4-4-2 to anything else, and coach Mauro Biello promptly adjusted and lined the team up in what appears to be a 4-2-3-1 against New England. Impact pulled out an impressive comeback victory against the Revolution in that first match, and have since tied two in the new formation. Was the change to the 4-2-3-1 the right move for the team? What does the formation allow Montreal to do that it could not do in the 4-4-2? Where in the formation does Ignacio Piatti perform best, out wide in space or in the center of the formation as the catalyst?

J. The 4-2-3-1 formation is one that the Impact have implemented frequently over the last few seasons. With the good start to the season and some of the injuries, I think that head coach Mauro Biello felt as though he could experiment a bit with the formation and lineup. In a best case scenario I think that the 4-2-3-1 is probably best for the Impact - but again it comes back to which players are available for selection on match day. Having said that, it is good that Biello has tried a few different formations out this season.

Nacho Piatti has been on a role this season and probably functions better out wide. He does have the ability to come into the middle when necessary and is a nice option to have during the match to give the the Montreal attack a little boost.

Q. Impact have not been the most stout team defensively over the course of the season, but the stats indicate that the team has been improving (6 goals in their last 5 games, compared with 1.5 goals per game in games prior). What appears to be working in the back that has improved the team defensively? How has the consistent pairing of the young Victor Cabrera and the veteran Laurent Ciman over the last two years begun to pay dividends?

J. The Impact defense certainly has its ups and downs. Laurent Ciman and Victor Cabrera have really grown together nicely over the last two seasons. One of the concerns has been the physicality of the Impact defenders in the box and it has proved costly while defending set pieces, as seen against Portland earlier this week. You can really see the difference when Ciman is in the lineup. Not only is he one of the best defenders in the league, he also plays a huge role in the organization of the defense when he is in the lineup. An underrated player in the Montreal set up is Donny Toia. He has just returned from a long injury and should be in the starting lineup on Sunday.

Have a prediction for the starting XI and match result?

J. With Ciman and Piatti set to miss the match Sunday there will be some changes to the Montreal lineup. 

Bush - Toia - Lefevre - Cabrera - Camara - Bernier - Alexander - Salazar - Venegas - Ontivero - Drogba

Result Prediction: 2-1 Montreal

Thanks to John Richan and Mount Royal Soccer for answering our questions ahead of the match. Have a different (better) prediction for the match this Sunday? Let us hear it in the comments section.

More From Hudson River Blue

  • 2023 Player Preview: Maximo Carrizo
  • 2023 Player Preview: Matt Freese
  • NYCFC 2023 Transfer Tracker: Announcements, rumors, sketchy tweets
  • NYCFC sign goalkeeper Matt Freese from Philadelphia Union
  • Sean Johnson joins Toronto FC
  • 2023 Player Preview: Gabriel Pereira

Most Read

  1. 2023 Player Preview: Maximo Carrizo The sky is the limit for the youngest-ever player to sign an MLS contract, but is he ready to make the leap to the Senior Team at age 15?
  2. NYCFC 2023 Transfer Tracker: Announcements, rumors, sketchy tweets Your hub for all breaking transfer news ahead of the 2023 season
Chorus
  • FanPosts
  • FanShots
  • Masthead
  • Community Guidelines
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Horizontal - White
  • Contact
  • Have a News Tip?
  • Browse Blogs
  • About SBN
  • Company Blog
  • Blog Openings
  • Editorial Ethics and Guidelines
Vox MediaVox Media Vox Media logo.
  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Notice
  • Cookie Policy
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Info
  • Licensing FAQ
  • Accessibility
  • Platform Status
  • Advertise with us
  • Jobs @ Vox Media
© 2023 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved

* 21+ (19+ CA-ONT) (18+ NH/WY). AZ, CO, CT, IL, IN, IA, KS, LA, (select parishes), MD, MI, NH, NJ, NY, OH, OR, PA, TN, VA, WV, WY, CA-ONT only.
Eligibility restrictions apply. Terms at draftkings.com/sportsbook. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Odds & lines subject to change.

Share this story

  • Twitter
  • Facebook