Skip to content

2023 Midterm Report Card: Player Ratings

Here are your cumulative player ratings for every member of the NYCFC squad, plus Nick Cushing, the refs, and the broadcast teams.

Teamwork makes the dream work |

Welcome to the 2023 edition of Hudson River Blue’s Midterm Report Cards, in which we analyze and grade New York City FC‘s performances so far this season. Next up: Player Ratings

NoteThe numbers below represent the cumulative ratings as determined by Hudson River Blue readers for each player over the first 17 MLS league games this season.

NYCFC Players

Talles Magno – 5.2

12 starts, 4 substitute appearances
There has been a TON of pressure on Talles Magno this season. Given his price tag, the talent he clearly has, and the departure of those around him, all eyes were turned to the 20-year-old to lead this team’s attack this season. Unfortunately, he hasn’t stepped up in the way fans, coaches, and the front office had probably hoped. 

This post is for subscribers only


Already have an account? Sign In