Skip to content

NYCFC vs St. Louis City Player Ratings

A first time for everything: Referee Erick Lezama earned the highest rating on the night, and is your POTM.

It was a good night for replacement referee Erick Lezama | Jeff Le-USA TODAY Sports

New York City FC might have a new-look kit and a new-look squad, but the first matches of the 2024 season are giving us flashbacks. Two games, zero goals, a total of four shots on target. We hate to say it, but these dismal results are becoming too familiar.

What's worse, this NYCFC is stacked, at least on paper: Two strikers, two No 10s, more wings than what you find in a chicken bucket. Nobody goes to CITYPARK expecting to dominate St. Louis City, but this NYCFC should have given the hosts more trouble.

Instead, we were left praying for a consolation goal. Is it too much to ask for a nice run of play that ends with a clinical finish? Just something to give us a little hope.

We had no such luck, and your Player Ratings reflect that. This is why, in a Hudson River Blue first, the referee earned the highest numbers on the night.

That's right, according to you, the replacement ref from Nicaragua had a better game than anybody wearing the 24/7 Kit. (Such a good shirt btw.)

Read on for your NYCFC vs St. Louis player ratings, and why we decided to name Erick Lezama your POTM — which today is short for Personnel of the Match.

This post is for subscribers only

Subscribe

Already have an account? Sign In

Latest

Oppo Research: 5 Things about Inter Miami

Oppo Research: 5 Things about Inter Miami

No Javier Mascherano? No problem: The Inter Miami head coach is suspended for the matchup with New York City FC at Citi Field, but the most valuable team in MLS history have Rodrigo de Paul, Dayne St. Clair, Mateo Silvetti, and a short-ish midfielder named Lionel Messi.

Members Public