We’re trying something new, and asking you to rate the New York City FC players who took the field in the agonizing 1-1 draw with the Chicago Fire. There’s a long tradition of rating players’ performances on a 10-point scale, and while there’s nothing scientific about the numbers this form will generate, it’s good fun.
NYCFC vs Chicago Fire: Rate the players
We invite you to rate the New York City players, head coach Nick Cushing, referee Filip Duijc, and the Apple TV broadcast team on a deadly 1-10 scale.
Related
Where's Talles Magno?
The Prodigal Winger returned to New York City FC at the start of preseason and took the #11 kit. But Talles Magno was absent from the lineup on Sunday, and wasn't spotted in training.
New York City FC 1-1 LAFC: 5 Thoughts
A New York City FC missing key players (and, ahem, a striker) played to a 1-1 draw under the bright, clear desert skies in their opening game at the 2026 Coachella Valley Invitational.
Taty Castellanos scores first Premier League goal for West Ham
Castellanos became the second-ever New York City FC export to score a goal in the English Premier League, his first goal helping West Ham United FC earn a critical win in their relegation survival battle.
2026 Coachella Valley Invitational preview
Talles Magno at the No 9? Kevin O'Toole in midfield? Here are the New York City FC players to watch at the 2026 Coachella Valley Invitational.
Latest
Where's Talles Magno?
The Prodigal Winger returned to New York City FC at the start of preseason and took the #11 kit. But Talles Magno was absent from the lineup on Sunday, and wasn't spotted in training.
New York City FC 1-1 LAFC: 5 Thoughts
A New York City FC missing key players (and, ahem, a striker) played to a 1-1 draw under the bright, clear desert skies in their opening game at the 2026 Coachella Valley Invitational.
Taty Castellanos scores first Premier League goal for West Ham
Castellanos became the second-ever New York City FC export to score a goal in the English Premier League, his first goal helping West Ham United FC earn a critical win in their relegation survival battle.
Cosmos mini-ticket plans start at $50 for four games
Pick a Plan ticket packages from the Cosmos start at $16.68 per ticket, and include the home opener vs Portland Hearts of Pine on March 7 for free: Here are the matchups we'd see.